Overhead Line Design Issues & Wind And Ice Storm Mitigation
Overhead Transmission Lines (OHL) often face severe ice or wind loads which may damage line sections and affect power supply to customers. Even when the best design criteria are met, there continues to be a risk of extensive damage to overhead lines when extreme wind or ice storms exceed the design criteria. Moreover, utilities should not ignore the anticipated effects of global warming and the substantial changes of climatic loads which might occur.
There are many approaches to limiting the impact of ice and wind loads on overhead lines. One may focus on a better knowledge of climatic events and their impacts on OHL, advancements in design, mitigation techniques or mutual assistance efforts.
- Climatic stations for recording ice or wind parameters and modeling for a better forecast of maximum loads.
- Careful selection of the design approach minimizes the risk of failures, while simultaneously reducing the potential consequences of such events.
- Mitigation techniques deal with the reduction of the consequences of exceeding the design loads or to avoid failure of installations by reducing ice accretion or by using de-icing techniques.
- Mutual assistance efforts focus on the sharing of resources, such as workers, logistics, equipment and components, in the event of serious damage.
Experiences with the 1998 ice storm in northeastern Canada and the U.S., several smaller ice storms, hurricanes and High Intensity Winds (HIW) recently occurring in many countries have demonstrated the devastation severe weather causes to transmission systems. These problems may best be addressed by improving knowledge and technologies, and by sharing the needed efforts on research and studies. The coalition of information on the most efficient storm management methods, collaboration on joint R&D projects and amalgamation of logistics and spare material will benefit all participants in this Interest Group.
Topics and Issues:
- Utility approaches to crisis management
- De-icing techniques during and following ice storms
- Failure containment and load control devices
- Prediction and real-time monitoring of loads
- Design for High Intensity Winds
- Inspection techniques to detect latent damage and aging
- Assessment of existing conductor vibration recorders
- Simulation of conductor galloping and galloping mitigation device assessment
- OHL protection against lightning without impairing line strength under ice loads
Current Projects
- Application Guide for Wind Speed-Up FactorsThis study will focus on wind speed-up factors due to specific local terrain features. The objective of this project is to develop an application guide by using the equations in the codes for a specified transmission line and comparing the results. A literature review will also be conducted to better understand wind behaviour under varying terrain characteristics.
- Guide for Design, Installation and Repair of ACSR Conductor SplicesThe objective of this project is, to review the existing practices of splice (both in-span and dead end) design, installation, in service testing standards and repair of poor functioning splices, and develop a guide for ACSR conductor splices. The review and guide will include the use of shunts for repair of splices.
- Transmission Line Monitoring Package for Extreme EventsThe objective of this project is to search, investigate and recommend a cost effective transmission line monitoring package (to monitor conductor icing and galloping, adverse vibrations, excessive temperatures, and wind speeds, etc). It would be desirable if the monitoring package includes sensors for detecting undesirable activities (vandalism, terrorism) or excessive movements near transmission support structures or components (towers, wood poles, guy anchors, etc).
- Corrosion Assessment of Tubular Steel PolesThe study will focus on corrosion assessment, material loss prediction and mitigation methods for near and below ground assessment of steel pole coating and material. The objective of this project is to critically evaluate measurement methods and non-intrusive techniques to assess their applicability, accuracy of results obtained and limitations (if any) for the existing condition assessment of below grade steel and coatings for steel tubular poles. This will include testing of various non-intrusive techniques at utility locations followed by excavation of the selected steel pole sites to compare actual condition with the results obtained with the predictions.
- Guide for Determining Deflection CriteriaThe objective of this investigation is to develop a guide for determining deflection criteria for transmission line support structures and foundations. This will focus on self-supported steel poles initially and will involve performing an analysis on a representative transmission line, considering a range of load conditions per NESC and/or select utility practices. Sensitivity analyses would be carried out by varying allowable structure and foundation displacements and assessing the impact. The deflection limits will be based on poor to average soil conditions (such as glacial clay, alluvial soil, etc.) and as a minimum load and sagging load (the sagging of conductors to one face of dead-end structure) conditions.
- Rime Icing Model Validation Using WRF and Full Scale Field Icing DataThe objective of this project is to collect full scale rime ice data on transmission size cable and validate this data using a Weather Research and Forecast (WRF) model. This will involve a comprehensive literature review to advance the current state of the art on rime icing models, followed by the collection of field data supplemented by a rime icing model validation using WRF. The Makkonen rime ice accretion model will be used under WRF, and the predicted load from WRF will be compared with those measured at the test span.
- Estimation of Safe Design Tension for TW (Compact) ACSR Conductors to Safeguard against Aeolian VibrationsThe objective of this project is to investigate and develop recommendations for safe design tension for undamped single and twisted pair (T2, VR) TW (compact) conductors. A secondary objective is to provide recommendations for damper placements on transmission line spans with TW conductors.
- Determination of Drag Coefficients for Ice Covered ConductorsThe objective of this project is to use Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) methods to obtain an accurate determination of the drag coefficients for commonly used transmission conductors (e.g., stranded conductors with round wires, stranded conductors with trapezoidal wires and twisted pair conductors).
- New Material for Replacing Copper for Grounding in the Transmission SystemThe objective of this project is to conduct research to find suitable materials which can be used by transmission utilities to replace copper as a grounding material. The project will review the material characteristics of copper, which is used as a grounding material by transmission utilities, and its installation and maintenance practices, and then conduct research to find a suitable material which could be used to replace copper as a grounding material. The new material must not be attractive to thieves and should involve little changes (if any) in utilities’ installation and maintenance practices.
- Development and Use of New Materials for Transmission Line Hardware Life ExtensionThe objective of this project is to investigate the root cause of premature failure of transmission line hardware and to explore alternative materials for use in transmission hardware items to provide longer functional life in the situations the existing hardware is fast wearing out. The new materials should also provide better dimensional control, so that installation of the items is easier and efficient.
- Robotic Maintenance and Its Implications for DesignThe objective of the project is to investigate and evaluate methods for robotic maintenance of transmission lines, specifically their impact on transmission line design practices, in that some changes might need to be made to accommodate those robotic maintenance practices. The applicability of the technologies will also be addressed as their deployment in live maintenance practices implies harsh and challenging operation conditions.
- Standardized Guidelines for LiDAR Survey of Transmission LinesThe objective of this project is to develop standard specifications for the data collection and output presentation of the transmission line LiDAR surveys. The consultant will critically review the available specifications to identify parameters that can be standardized. The practices from at least five vendors will also be reviewed to study the differences in the equipment used, data collection format and result outputs. Ultimately, this work will result in the development of standardized guidelines for conducting or commissioning LiDAR surveys of transmission lines.
- Best Practices for Emergency Restoration Methods under Extreme EventsThe objective of the project is to gather information on the practices used by utilities for emergency restoration during extreme events, compile lessons learned, and suggest improvements to the practices. It is intended that this project may capitalize on lessons already learned by summarizing past events and examining what should be done to expedite the process after an extreme event. Being better prepared means resuming normal operations quicker and in a safer way than before.
- Methodology to Determine Transmission Line Life Cycle CostsThe objective of this project is to develop a methodology for conducting the life cycle cost analysis for determining the most cost-effective option for building a new transmission line or upgrading a line in an existing corridor.
- Technology Watch on New Conductors for Transmission LinesThe objective of this project is to prepare a state of the art report containing details about these new high temperature low sag (HTLS) conductors, the situations under which they should be used, the experience gained so far in their use, the gaps in knowledge, their initial and life cycle costs, and any known construction and maintenance issues, etc.
- End of Life of Wood ComponentsThe objective of this project is to survey utilities regarding their criteria for evaluation of in-service life and remaining capacity of wood pole. This is intended to identify methods to accurately determine the current strength and predict the remaining life of wood components, and to identify the gaps in knowledge for future work.
- New Structural Materials for Transmission LinesThe objective of this project is to critically review the materials currently being used for transmission line structural components including grounding electrodes, the requirements which such materials have to meet, and their inherent limitations, and to investigate and recommend alternative, cost-effective materials which are construction-friendly, provide longer design life and require minimal maintenance.
- Guide to Reconductoring and Uprating Transmission LinesThe objective of this project is to prepare a guide including a discussion of various methods and best practices of reconductoring and uprating transmission lines to increase the power transfer capacity of the existing transmission network. The guide will include recommendations on the method(s) to be used, stating the conditions under which the particular method is most efficient. It will also include case studies supporting the recommendations.
- Corrosion of Transmission Line ComponentsThe purpose of this project would be to gain experience with the developing non-destructive evaluation (NDE) technologies and learn more about their potential applicability on transmission systems. Two WISMIG utilities (BCTC and NYPA) have already begun employing these methods in their field assessment practices. Their experiences will be analyzed and reviewed as part of this project.
- Methods for Conducting Extreme Event Model SimulationsThe objectives of this work are to provide computational methods and models that can be used by individual utilities to address the risk of damage and outage due to extreme wind, ice and earthquake. The methods and models are geared to accommodate each utility's prior design practices, and future extreme hazards (wind, ice, earthquake). The work includes benefit-cost tools that can be used to develop rational mitigation / emergency response plans that are tailored to each individual utility's needs. All methods will be presented in forms that can be custom-tailored for individual utilities. All data and models will be presented in Excel worksheets, so that they can be readily used by any utility.
- Development of a Vision Based Real-Time Ice Detection SystemThe current ice detection system uses a large variety of off-shell devices housed in a weather proof enclosure. Development work on integrating functions of these various devices into custom control boards will result in significant 2 / 6 reductions in components required, system size and overall unit cost. The system integration will also improve operation reliability, and facilitate commissioning and maintenance processes. In addition, efforts are required to enhance the existing graphical user interface for large system installation. This project proposes to install a precision mechanical weighing system in order to detect this change in density. By combining ice profiles obtained from the developed ice detection system and density data in real time, it should be possible to predict rate of change of the transformation of hoarfrost into ice and provide an early warning indication. This project focuses on the continued development of real-time monitoring of ice accumulation. The research component of this work involves the additional hardware and software required to monitor the transformation of hoarfrost into ice.
- Conductor Fatigue Work for AGS Suspension ClampsArmor Grip Suspension (AGS) clamps with helical rod attachments have been used on transmission lines for many years but their use is not as widespread as metal-to-metal clamps. AGS clamps are designed to provide greater tolerance to higher levels of vibration than metal-to-metal clamps. Conductor fatigue studies in AGS suspension clamps are to be considered. To reduce overall test time, emphasis should be to coax conductor (or clamp) failures at high vibration levels. It is suggested that this project should consider conductors built with trapezoidal wires as well as round wires. Studies could also be conducted to compare the relative vibration behavior of undamped metal-to-metal clamps to undamped AGS clamps for the same size conductors. This project will look at conductor fatigue in AGS clamps, and it will compare the relative vibration behavior of undamped metal-metal clamps to undamped AGS clamps. It will also evaluate claims that AGS clamps are designed to offer suspension systems that are less prone to conductor fatigue.
- Guide to Best Practices for the Design of 138-230 kV Overhead Transmission LinesThe objective of this study is to prepare a guide to the best design practices including a recommended design for a 138-230 kV single circuit overhead transmission line. The study shall include the pros and cons, and relative costs (including life cycle costs), amongst the various options and methods for designing and constructing lines. It will include design for 1) lines in congested urban areas, 2) lines in gently rolling rural areas, and 3) lines in mountainous areas.
- Guide to Assist Utility Engineers in Costing the Consequence of Failure of an Overhead Transmission LineThe costs associated with the failure of an OHL is not only composed of tangible costs, like the reconstruction cost and the money losses of the utility for not delivering energy, but the intangible costs like the costs related to the customers not being able to use their facilities, costs of compensation and penalties, and cost associated with the negative publicity for the company. Those costs are also dependent on the line function in the network and the design criteria used for the network operation based on various indices (SAIFI and SAIDI). WISMIG members have expressed the need of a guide to determine the cost of the consequence of failure of an overhead transmission line.
- Benchmark Study for a Line Modeled in ADINA (Stick Model) with Various Anti-Cascading StructuresThe primary objective of this project is to carry out a benchmark study for a line modeled in ADINA (Stick model) with various anti cascading structures. These are: White Anticascade structure, Regular Suspension with increased Longitudinal Strength, Full dead end, and Guyed Dead End at the Bridge level. The objective of this study would be to compute the estimated peak load that the containment structure would see and compare the load in a relative sense. Also cost can be determined based on the load estimated and a ranking can be done based on the effectiveness of the structure to withstand the load.
- Modelling and Prediction of Failure of Transmission Lines Due to High Intensity WindsThis project is a 3-year program whose objectives are:
- The testing of tower/line physical models in a novel large-scale downburst simulator (based on a wall jet), with comparison to conventional loads derived from atmospheric boundary layer profile wind tests on those models.
- The validation of the tornado CFD model using new data from a tornadic chamber.
- The completion of a simplified downburst loading model and corresponding tornado load model.
- The development of a downburst risk model for the electrical system.
These concepts are to be applied to utility tower/line systems.
Recently Completed Projects
More Publications...
| Date | Location |
|---|---|
| October 1-3, 2012 | Tampa, FL, USA |
| April 8-9, 2013 | San Diego, CA, USA |
| October 2-4, 2013 | Montreal, QC, Canada |









